12 Most Popular Feel-Good Ice Cream Flavors

Happy Young Woman With Delicious Ice Cream In Waffle Cone

The ideal dessert for every occasion is ice cream. And it’s hard to pick a favorite among the more than a thousand varieties available! Fortunately, we’ve reduced it to the top 12 ice cream flavors. Rest assured, we have included one item for each category—classic, nutty, fruity, and chunky.

Homemade Vanilla

Ice Cream Cone
Source: Shutterstock

It makes sense that vanilla is first on the list, as the majority of people around the world love this flavor. One user says, “This is the best flavor. You can do anything with this since it has the potential, and is pure.” Another adds, “It can elevate anything: apple pie, chocolate brownie, and any flavor milkshake. They are made better with vanilla ice cream.”

Cookie Two Step

Brenham Texas June 12 2019: Pov Hand Holding Ice
Source: Shutterstock

Another popular ice cream flavor is Blue Bell’s Cookie Two Step. This vanilla ice cream features a mix of chocolate crème cookies and chocolate chip cookie dough with hints of brown sugar for irresistible flavors. “It is the best. However, it’s almost always sold out at my grocery stores,” writes a user.  

Cookies and Cream

Clear Glass Bowl Of Cookies And Cream Ice Cream. Selective
Source: Shutterstock

Ice cream enthusiasts also recommend cookies and cream, made of vanilla ice cream with bits of chocolate cookies. 

Peanut Butter and Chocolate

Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Source: Shutterstock

“Salted ice creams are highly underrated,” mentions a user who loves peanut butter and chocolate ice cream. You get a perfect blend of creamy, nutty, and sweet flavors. 

If you can’t find peanut butter and chocolate ice cream at your local store, one user recommends, “Just scoop some peanut butter out of a jar and pile it in. The contrast between the room temperature peanut butter and the cold ice cream is like heaven.”

Moose Tracks

Homemade Moose Tracks Ice Cream In A Bowl
Source: Shutterstock

Another yummy favorite flavor is Moose Tracks which melts your taste buds. One foreigner writes, “I went to America when I was 13 and still haven’t found an ice cream in the same league. OMG, Moose Tracks!”

Mint Chocolate Chip

Organic Green Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream With A Spoon
Source: Shutterstock

This is the “perfect balance” ice cream for some enthusiasts, although others feel that mint and chocolate should not be served together.  


Pistachio Ice Cream
Source: Shutterstock

One post reads, “I am glad this is on the list because even low pistachio ice cream is very good. Making it yourself with well-selected ingredients is a bucket list-worthy endeavor.” Another poster adds, “(I am) not sure why pistachio ice cream works, but it does.”

Butter Pecan

Butter Pecan Ice Cream In A White Bowl In Rustic
Source: Shutterstock

This ice cream is an undisputable favorite “as far as traditional flavors go,” says a poster. Another post reads, “I moved to Europe a while ago, and this is one of the things I miss most about America.”

Cookie Dough

Frozen Cookie Dough Ice Cream Ready To Eat For Dessert
Source: Shutterstock

Ben and Jerry’s was the first company to invent Cookie Dough ice cream in 1984. It blends crunchy chocolate chips and chunks of raw cookie dough. Although some people initially find it weird, they admit that the flavors are irresistible. 


Coffee Ice Cream Decorated With Coffee Beans On Rustic Wooden
Source: Shutterstock

Coffee ice cream also makes the day for some people, especially big coffee drinkers. One commentator explains she loves pouring an espresso on her coffee-flavored ice cream. Another mentions she enjoys the ice cream with chocolate sprinkles. 

Black Raspberry

Delicious Berry Blackberry Purple Ice Cream On Gray Stone Table
Source: Shutterstock

Black raspberries have a sweet, tart taste that makes you crave more when added to ice cream. 

Half Baked

Winneconne Wi 12 May 2016: Container Of Ben &
Source: Shutterstock

Ben and Jerry’s Half Baked is another fantastic ice cream flavor. “It seems you either get cookie dough or fudge brownie in every bite,” points out a poster. 

Source: Reddit
Featured Photo from Shutterstock

12 Unspoken Rules That Are Not Completely Obvious

Source: Shutterstock

12 Unspoken Rules That Are Not Completely Obvious

21 British Words That Are Confusing to Americans

Young Man In Detestation
Photo by SIphotography on Deposit Photos

21 British Phrases That Are Confusing to Americans

10 Worst Things About Owning an Electric Vehicle

Depositphotos 229829956 L
Photo by Prostock on Deposit Photos

10 Worst Things About Owning an Electric Vehicle

10 Words and Phrases That Make You Sound Stupid

Businessman Covers Face With Hand. Guy Facepalms Feeling Ashamed Of
Source: Shutterstock

10 Words and Phrases That Make You Sound Stupid

Dad Answers All